Page 204 - 2024-Vol20-Issue2

200 | Al-mtory, Alnahwi & Ali

TABLE V.
PERFORMANCE COMPARISON FOR THE BEST COST OF THE SIX ALGORITHMS WITH 1000 ITERATIONS, 30 RUNS AND

VARIABLE DIMENSION = 20

FUN# Method Best Mean Std. Median SR%

FUN1 CDOA. 8.61E-13 4.343590E-06 0.00001 3.34E-06 100
Modified CA 4.28E-13 0.000000000001 2.497574E-12 2.73E-13 100
1.8274E-12 3.47E-12 100
FKE 2.25E-08 2.001E-10 8.162E-10 6.79E-06 100
CSA 2.536E-11 5.48E-07 3.36E-05 4.578E-10 100
PSO 0.0005476 1.478E-09 1.5E-09 0.006715 100
SCA 0.006578 0.00421

FUN2 CDOA. 1.02E-18 3.1268824E-06 3.996994E-06 1.65E-06 100
Modified CA 6.24E-14 0.0000000000015 1.803449E-12 8.40E-13 100
9.4182E-12 4.7726E-10 8.40E-11 100
FKE 6.94E-11 1.390E-9 6.48E-10 100
CSA 6.55E-30 4.72E-10 7.76E-09 1.36E-26 100
PSO 0.00099173 2.60E-28 1.64E-26 0.0067941 100
SCA 0.002846 0.00337

FUN3 CDOA. 1.89E-12 3.1365680E-08 4.576027E-08 1.82E-08 100
Modified CA 2.14E-15 5.5209666E-14 9.923128E-14 3.65E-14 100
1.0849E-13 8.6103E-12 8.889E-12 100
FKE 6.49E-09 7.5104E-12 2.82E-08 100
CSA 3.65E-21 3.42E-08 3.80E-07 6.48E-20 100
PSO 0.0036749 3.50E-18 6.48E-17 0.022457 93.33
SCA 0.0045679 0.06479

FUN4 CDOA. 1.15E-11 0.0000033 4.576027E-08 2.78E-06 90
Modified CA 4.45E-15 4.63056667E-14 3.445415E-14 4.87E-14 100
3.591E-9 8.4139E-06 5.827E-04 86.66
FKE 2.59E-03 2.956E-4 3.15E-02 40
CSA 8.21E-13 9.90E-01 1.00E+00 6.21E-10 100
PSO 6.48E-03 9.88E-12 1.56E-11 6.48E-02 70
SCA 9.97E-03 1.21E-02

FUN5 CDOA. 1.76E-11 3.0391017E-06 0.00000442 7.31E-07 100
Modified CA 6.52E-05 0.0171 0.02164 1.07E-03 50
1.184E-04 0.00247 0.003357 8.426E-03 56.66
FKE 8.67E-04 0.57894 0.87614 1.00324 26
CSA 0.8736 0.83201 1.0457 50
PSO 0 0.065134 7.30E-02 -0.0090247 53
SCA -0.0088745

FUN6 CDOA. 2.87E-08 0.0002 0.00042 1.00E-04 100
Modified CA 1.21E-09 1.9891667E-08 2.401251E-08 1.38E-08 100
9.0648E-08 1.9472E-07 7.5936E-06 100
FKE 0.024567 4.7263E-07 5.98461
CSA 5.0147 3.657 1.6794 0
PSO 0 1.5367 1.4249 0.30497 30
SCA 0.008674 0.07894 8.86E-02 43