Page 201 - 2024-Vol20-Issue2

197 | Al-mtory, Alnahwi & Ali

TABLE II.
PERFORMANCE COMPARISON FOR THE BEST COST OF THE SIX ALGORITHMS WITH 1000 ITERATIONS, 30 RUNS AND

VARIABLE DIMENSION = 5

FUN# Method Best Mean Std. Median SR%

FUN1 CDOA. 8.91E-210 1.7740581E-56 4.0924500E-57 9.98E-97 100
Modified CA 1.18E-29 8.06E-25 2.27E-24 9.04E-27 100
3.456E-50 1.11E-28 7.9845E-29 100
FKE 1.87E-20 6.7632E-30 4.49E-18 7.21E-19 100
CSA 2.28E-18 0 100
PSO 0 0 5.61E-05 0 100
SCA 5.17E-08 0.00004 6.13E-07

FUN2 CDOA. 1.75E-236 2.3733333E-59 1.29992820E-58 1.67E-111 100
Modified CA 5.24E-27 1.12E-24 2.24E-24 1.24E-25 100
7.5865E-29 3.332E-26 2.67E-26 100
FKE 1.79E-20 3.78627E-27 4.28E-18 9.18E-19 100
CSA 2.08E-18 0 100
PSO 0 0 0.00036 0 100
SCA 0.080856 0.080972 0.091922

FUN3 CDOA. 6.37E-204 6.7520666E-57 3.68765899E-56 3.82E-99 100
Modified CA 2.49E-23 7.46E-18 1.75E-17 6.45E-19 100
1.389E-27 8.429E-20 8.765E-19 5.412E-22 100
FKE 1.17E-21 1.28E-15 4.38E-15 5.47E-17 100
CSA 0 0 100
PSO 0 0.0089954 0.00032 0 85
SCA 0.009435 0.08864

FUN4 CDOA. 4.44E-15 9.7032666E-14 2.6550080E-13 7.99E-15 100
Modified CA 3.29E-14 1.14E-11 2.26E-11 3.93E-12 100
2.182E-15 2.751E-10 1.7193E-9 1.729E-9 100
FKE 2.19E-09 9.39E-09 4.32E-09 8.75E-09 100
CSA 4.35E-14 0.1142 0.3527 1.13E-12 93
PSO 0.008321 4.02E-08 0.009953 70
SCA 0.00066785

FUN5 CDOA. 1.21E-189 7.1333333E-60 3.90708757E-59 1.12E-93 100
Modified CA 0 0 0.0073 0.0099 60
3.629E-51 100
FKE 2.447E-121 5.193E-33 2.221E-28 0.0123 50
CSA 0 0.0131 0.0107 0.016 50
PSO 0 0.0171 0.0171 0.062754 45
SCA 4.02E-06
0.0071067 0.0071037

FUN6 CDOA. 5.56E-163 9.233333E-61 5.057304E-60 2.82E-89 100
Modified CA 0 4.77E-09 2.61E-08 0 100
0 1.188E-15 3.3664E-14 100
FKE 0 1.3598 0.9944 1.519E-14 20
CSA 0 0.4643 0.8152 0.995 67
PSO 0.0000439 0 95
SCA 0.00005643 6.87695E-07
0.0006675