Page 203 - 2024-Vol20-Issue2

199 | Al-mtory, Alnahwi & Ali

TABLE IV.
PERFORMANCE COMPARISON FOR THE BEST COST OF THE SIX ALGORITHMS WITH 1000 ITERATIONS, 30 RUN AND

VARIABLE DIMENSION = 15

FUN# Method Best Mean Std. Median SR%
FUN1 CDOA. 1.79E-18 1.7658937E-15 1.347340E-10 9.62E-14 100
Modified CA 8.93E-17 7.0285433E-15 1.178094E-14 3.19E-15 100
FUN2 1.639E-17 8.3173492E-14 3.6142E-13 100
FKE 5.80E-09 5.19412E-9 4.79E-08 100
CSA 5.68E-08 3.68E-06 100
PSO 0 0 0 100
SCA 0.00009671 0 0.0001156 100
CDOA. 0.0006719 0.00036 3.73E-11 100
Modified CA 1.46E-16 2.7790667E-07 6.150042E-07 3.25E-15 100
FKE 9.52E-17 9.58720667E-15 1.583618E-14 6.4196E-10 100
CSA 4.1936E-14 3.8412E-6 9.57E-11 100
PSO 2.57E-12 7.206E-6 6.55E-10 100
SCA 6.87E-11 0
0 0 0.0002257
0.00004872 0 0.001
0.0009475

FUN3 CDOA. 3.99E-21 5.6101150E-09 1.501606E-08 1.06E-11 100
FUN4 Modified CA 1.59E-17 4.4628E-16 1.101611E-15 1.14E-16 100
FUN5 2.8583E-19 2.4817E-08 2.741E-10 100
FKE 9.67E-10 9.85E-09 5.1935E-07 9.75E-09 100
CSA 0 8.71E-08 100
PSO 0 0.0009846 0 100
SCA 0.0001157 0 0.003741 100
CDOA. 1.11E-21 3.537724082E-09 0.00087 1.06E-12 100
Modified CA 1.08E-15 0.00000000000026 1.053506E-08 1.63E-13 100
FKE 2.0381E-20 2.813018E-13 1.7429E-11 46
CSA 6.15E-04 5.281E-08 7.2481E-07 4.58E-03 100
PSO 6.84E-13 9.67E-01 9.75E-01 5.48E-10 83
SCA 2.25E-03 7.35E-12 9.74E-12 1.11E-02 84
CDOA. 5.78E-16 8.29E-03 9.17E-03 3.50E-07 43
Modified CA 3.66E-05 0.0057 0.01319 7.32E-02 40
FKE 6.195E-08 0.0754 0.04497 9.420E-02 30
CSA 3.46E-05 0.0931 0.06342 0.9745 27
PSO 0.3357 0.5486 0.9974 66
SCA 0 0.6485 0.7435 -0.77642
-0.06843 0.036419 2.21E-02

FUN6 CDOA. 1.60E-20 4.22325632E-08 1.077977E-07 5.59E-11 100
Modified CA 1.24E-17 1.37837133E-14 2.434454E-14 2.57E-15 100
2.052E-19 5.91302481E-08 4.719304E-06 7.019283E-10 100
FKE 4.1297 6
CSA 0 4.6547 2.0021 1.5697 33
PSO 0 1.3479 1.27941 0.2347 56
SCA 0.0044587 0.068721 6.57E-02