Page 202 - 2024-Vol20-Issue2

198 | Al-mtory, Alnahwi & Ali

TABLE III.
PERFORMANCE COMPARISON FOR THE BEST COST OF THE SIX ALGORITHMS WITH 1000 ITERATIONS, 30 RUNS AND

VARIABLE DIMENSION = 10

FUN# Method Best Mean Std. Median SR%

CDOA. 8.34E-23 7.8456444E-07 4.0852034E-06 1.35E-17 100

Modified CA 5.07E-20 1.60E-17 5.61E-17 2.07E-18 100

FUN1 FKE 4.822E-19 3.775E-18 4.662E-16 3.101E-17 100
CSA 1.14E-19 1.70E-18 2.44E-18 8.03E-19 100
PSO 100
0 0 0 0

SCA 1.46E-07 2.70E-05 6.02E-05 2.57E-06 100
9.86E-21 6.66E-23 100
SCA 9.15E-24 5.71E-21

CDOA. 1.55E-23 8.7531616E-07 4.7830732E-06 2.47E-16 100
100
Modified CA 3.27E-20 1.68E-17 2.61E-17 2.96E-18

FUN2 FKE 1.001E-19 2.311E-16 3.85E-16 4.1073E-17 100
CSA 1.25E-19 2.73E-17 3.35E-18 7.12E-18 100
PSO 0 100
0 0 0

SCA 6.59325E-07 2.59838E-05 8.9E-05 8.69E-06 100

FUN3 CDOA. 2.23E-24 2.9200013E-06 0.00001 6.81E-19 100
Modified CA 2.40E-16 4.34E-14 7.06E-14 1.43E-14 100
7.926E-15 9.251E-13 1.395E-13 2.592E-13 100
FKE 8.03E-12 1.24E-09 2.05E-09 3.26E-10 100
CSA

PSO 0 0 0 0 100
6.5E-07 2.976E-06 100
SCA 1.9732E-06 0.0000024

CDOA. 1.07E-24 0.000013 0.00005 7.38E-15 100

Modified CA 3.26E-10 2.72E-08 5.81E-08 1.36E-08 100

FUN4 FKE 1.096E-9 3.966E-07 4.27E-07 7.553E-07 100
CSA 3.14E-06 8.25E-01 9.58E-01 5.73E-04 57
PSO 4.44E-15 5.27E-15 1.53E-15 4.44E-15 100

SCA 5.98E-05 2.46E-04 3.57E-04 6.87E-03 90

FUN5 CDOA. 7.58E-18 4.9596798E-06 0.00003 1.18E-12 100
Modified CA 0 0.0583 0.0282 0.0253 50
0.000024 0.00415 56.667
FKE 2.443E-12 2.467E-04 0.0306 0.032 37
CSA 1.24E-10 0.0416 0.0374 0.0363 30
PSO 0.0641 7.18E-06 -0.0099654 70
SCA 0
-0.0071067 0.0071011

CDOA. 2.73E-25 1.32000004E-08 4.3326666E-08 1.77E-18 100

Modified CA 0 9.47E-09 5.19E-15 0 100
4.592E-21 1.629E-06 8.264E-06 2.639E-14 100
FUN6 FKE 10
CSA 0 3.6482 1.7786 3.9798

PSO 0 0.796 0.661 0.995 43

SCA 0.00004598 0.005697 2.46E-03 0.0005699 65